约9分钟阅读
问题—解决型写作是最实用、使用最广泛的非虚构写作形式之一。无论你是在写学术论文、商业提案、政策备忘录,还是评论专栏,清楚地找出一个问题并提出一个有理有据的解决方案,都是一项几乎可以迁移到所有职业和学术语境中的技能。本节介绍问题—解决型写作的结构、目的和应用,让你能有把握地着手去写。
问题—解决型写作(problem-solution writing)是说明性或议论性写作的一种体裁,作者在其中:
从根本上说,问题—解决型写作回答两个问题:出了什么问题? 以及 我们应该怎么办? 作者的任务,是让读者相信这个问题真实存在而且很重要,所提出的解决方案切实可行、行之有效、值得推行。
这种体裁不同于纯粹的信息性写作,因为它要求作者表明立场。你不只是在报告事实——你是在倡导行动。它也不同于纯粹的论证,因为它扎根于务实:重点在于可行的解决方案,而不只是证明一个观点。
虽然问题—解决型文章可以用好几种方式来组织,但它们一般遵循一个四部分的结构:
开头确立话题,并提供足够的背景,让读者理解情况。它通常以一个论点句结尾,这个论点句会同时预告问题和所提出的解决方案(或者表明主体部分会提出一个解决方案)。
论点句示例: While urban food deserts have worsened health outcomes in low-income neighborhoods for decades, a combination of mobile farmers' markets and community garden programs can significantly improve access to fresh produce in these underserved areas.
在这一部分,你要界定、描述问题,并确立它的重要性。目标是让读者明白问题是什么、影响谁、为什么重要,以及有多严重。有力的问题部分会用论据——数据、专家证词、现实中的例子——来证明这个问题值得关注。
在这一部分,你要提出你的解决方案(一个或多个)。你要解释这个方案包括什么、怎样实施、为什么能奏效,以及有什么论据支撑它的有效性。有力的解决方案部分还会回应可能的反对意见、局限或成本。
结论强化问题与解决方案之间的联系,概括关键论证,并且常常包含一个行动呼吁——呼吁读者支持、实施或进一步研究所提出的解决方案。
问题—解决型写作可以用几种方式来组织,取决于话题的复杂程度和所提出的解决方案的数量。
最常见的模式。文章的前半部分完全聚焦于问题,后半部分完全聚焦于解决方案。
| 部分 | 内容 |
|---|---|
| 引言 | 背景 + 论点句 |
| 主体段 1–3 | 问题:描述、论据、影响 |
| 主体段 4–6 | 解决方案:提议、论据、实施 |
| 结论 | 总结 + 行动呼吁 |
当问题需要大量解释、读者才能体会到解决方案的价值时,这种模式效果最好。
每个段落或每个部分先呈现问题的一个具体方面,紧接着呈现解决方案中相应的方面。
| 部分 | 内容 |
|---|---|
| 引言 | 背景 + 论点句 |
| 主体段 1 | 问题的方面 A + 针对 A 的解决方案 |
| 主体段 2 | 问题的方面 B + 针对 B 的解决方案 |
| 主体段 3 | 问题的方面 C + 针对 C 的解决方案 |
| 结论 | 总结 + 行动呼吁 |
当问题有多个不同的层面、每个层面都需要有针对性的应对时,这种模式效果很好。
先呈现问题,接着给出几个可能的解决方案。作者对每个方案作出评估,并可能推荐其中一个。
| 部分 | 内容 |
|---|---|
| 引言 | 背景 + 论点句 |
| 主体段 1–2 | 问题描述 |
| 主体段 3 | 方案 A:描述 + 评估 |
| 主体段 4 | 方案 B:描述 + 评估 |
| 主体段 5 | 方案 C:描述 + 评估 |
| 主体段 6 | 推荐的方案及其理由 |
| 结论 | 总结 + 行动呼吁 |
这种模式常见于政策写作、商业提案和研究论文中,因为在这些场合需要权衡多种选择。
每当你需要做以下事情时,问题—解决型写作都是合适的:
在学术环境中,问题—解决型文章常见于:
在工作场所,问题—解决式的思维是以下工作的基础:
问题—解决型写作本质上是说服性的。你不只是在描述一种情况——你是在论证某样东西需要改变,而你提出的改变是正确的。这意味着你必须:
在动笔之前,要意识到那些会削弱问题—解决型文章的错误:
如果问题被描述得含糊或过于笼统,读者就不会感到紧迫。"Pollution is bad" 激发不了行动;"Particulate matter from diesel trucks exceeds safe levels in 85% of urban school zones" 才能。
解决方案必须直接针对问题部分所描述的原因或后果。如果你花了三段来解释问题是由陈旧的基础设施造成的,你的解决方案就应该针对基础设施——而不是公众宣传活动。
一个无法实施的绝妙方案毫无用处。读者想知道:谁来做?要花多少钱?需要多长时间?需要哪些资源?不回应可行性问题,会损害你的可信度。
有些问题有深层的结构性原因,简单的修补无法解决。承认复杂性,能让你的文章更诚实、更有说服力。比起一位声称 "This one change will fix everything" 的作者,读者更可能信任一位说 "This solution addresses the most significant factor" 的作者。
如果你的解决方案面临明显的反对意见,无视它们会显得你没有把问题想透。直接回应反方意见,并解释为什么尽管有局限,你的方案仍然是现有的最佳选择。
除了文章结构之外,问题—解决式的思维还是一种可以迁移的思维技能。它训练你:
| 概念 | 要点 |
|---|---|
| 定义 | 找出一个问题并提出解决方案的写作 |
| 核心结构 | 引言、问题、解决方案、结论 |
| 组织模式 | 分块式、交替式、多方案式 |
| 什么时候用 | 倡导、提案、学术论文、标准化考试、职场报告 |
| 说服方面的要求 | 可信度、论据、读者意识、处理反方意见 |
| 常见误区 | 问题含糊、方案不匹配、忽视可行性、过度简化、忽视反对意见 |
约10分钟阅读
任何一篇问题—解决型文章的力量,都取决于问题界定得有多好。问题界定得不好,就会导致软弱的解决方案、无法令人信服的论证,以及提不起兴趣的读者。相反,一个界定清楚的问题会营造一种紧迫感,让读者想看到解决方案。本节讲解确立重要性、界定范围、营造紧迫感和说明谁受到影响的基本技巧。
看看同一篇文章的两个开头段落:
版本 A: Traffic is a problem in many cities. It causes delays and makes people frustrated. Something should be done about it.
版本 B: In Los Angeles, the average commuter spends 119 hours per year stuck in traffic -- the equivalent of nearly three full work weeks. This congestion costs the city's economy an estimated $19.2 billion annually in lost productivity, wasted fuel, and increased freight costs. For the 500,000 low-income workers who depend on public buses that share these congested roads, the impact is even more severe: longer commutes mean less time with their families, fewer hours available for second jobs, and reduced access to healthcare appointments.
版本 A 描述的问题太含糊,激发不了行动。版本 B 用具体的细节、论据和对人的影响来界定同一个问题——让读者在乎,并为一个有说服力的解决方案打好基础。
你文章中的问题部分要做三件关键的事:
有效的问题界定会涉及五个维度。并不是每篇文章都会以同等的深度涵盖全部五个维度,但优秀的作者会把每一个都考虑到。
先清楚、准确地说出问题。避免含糊的措辞。读者读完你开头的描述后,应该能准确地理解问题出在哪里。
说明问题性质的技巧:
提示: 问问自己「五个为什么」(the "Five Whys")。从问题出发,连问五次「为什么?」,每一次都向更深的原因挖掘。
问题:Student test scores are declining. 为什么?Students are not retaining material. 为什么?They are not engaging with the content during class. 为什么?Lecture-based teaching does not require active participation. 为什么?Teachers have not been trained in active learning methods. 为什么?Professional development budgets were cut three years ago.
真正的问题也许不是考试成绩下降,而是对教师培训投入不足。
范围告诉读者问题有多普遍。它是地方性的、地区性的、全国性的,还是全球性的?它影响的是少数人还是数百万人?它局限于一个行业,还是跨越多个领域?
确立范围的技巧:
范围赋予问题分量。一个影响数百万人的问题需要关注;一个正在扩大的问题需要紧迫地对待。
重要性不止于统计数据。它回答的问题是:So what?(那又怎样?)读者为什么应该在乎?如果问题继续得不到遏制,会有什么后果?
确立重要性的技巧:
最有说服力的问题部分,会把硬数据(统计数据、代价、趋势)与人的故事(轶事、案例研究、证词)结合起来。数据赋予问题规模,故事赋予问题面孔。
紧迫性回答的问题是:为什么这件事不能等?如果读者读完问题部分,觉得这个问题很严重、却不急于一时,他们就不太可能被解决方案打动。
营造紧迫感的技巧:
找出谁受到问题的影响,能帮助读者理解问题的人的维度,也能说明谁会从解决方案中受益。
找出利益相关方的技巧:
下面是构建一个有效的问题部分的实用流程:
动笔之前,先收集论据。寻找:
表面的问题往往有更深的原因。如果你的解决方案针对的是根本原因而不是症状,它会更有效。
| 表面问题 | 根本原因 |
|---|---|
| 员工流失率高 | 管理文化不佳、薪酬低于市场水平 |
| 学生成绩低 | 学校资金不足、教室过于拥挤、缺乏教师培训 |
| 医疗费用上涨 | 按服务收费的支付模式鼓励追求数量而非疗效 |
| 城市交通拥堵 | 依赖汽车的土地利用规划、公共交通投入不足 |
| 食物浪费 | 淘汰可食用农产品的外观标准、令人困惑的保质期标签 |
为问题部分确定一种组织策略:
问题部分的每一个主张都应该有具体的论据支撑。用具体的细节替换含糊的断言。
| 含糊 | 具体 |
|---|---|
| Many people are affected | 23 million Americans lack access to broadband internet |
| The cost is high | Cybercrime costs the global economy $6 trillion annually |
| The problem has been getting worse | Ocean plastic pollution has doubled since 2010 |
| Some students struggle | 54% of U.S. adults read below a sixth-grade level |
| It impacts health | Air pollution causes an estimated 9 million premature deaths per year worldwide |
光有数据是不够的。至少加入一个能帮助读者感受到问题对人的影响的元素——一个轶事、一个案例研究,或者一段对问题在实际中是什么样子的生动描述。
有效的问题部分会平衡诉诸逻辑(logos,逻辑上的论据)和诉诸情感(pathos,情感上的感染)。只有逻辑没有情感,会显得枯燥、学究气;只有情感没有逻辑,会显得操纵人心、缺乏根据。
一个有效的技巧,是在数据和叙述之间交替:
例:
Every year, approximately 800,000 people worldwide die by suicide -- one person every 40 seconds. [数据]
James, a 22-year-old college senior, struggled with depression for three years before seeking help. By the time he finally visited his university's counseling center, the waitlist was six weeks long. He never made it to his appointment. [故事]
James's experience is not unusual. A 2023 survey found that 60% of college counseling centers have waitlists, with an average wait time of 25 business days. At the moment when students most need support, the system designed to help them is overwhelmed. [数据]
这种结构既给了读者问题的规模(统计数据),也给了它一张人的面孔(James 的故事),让论证在思想上令人信服、在情感上引起共鸣。
不要以为读者已经认同问题很严重。即使是众所周知的问题,也需要论据和框架。"Everyone knows climate change is bad" 不能代替关于其影响的具体论据。
如果你只描述问题表面上是什么样子(症状),你的解决方案就会流于表面。要深挖问题为什么存在。
一个太宽泛的问题,无法在一篇文章中得到解决。"Global poverty" 太大了。"The lack of affordable childcare prevents low-income mothers in urban areas from maintaining full-time employment" 才聚焦到足以有意义地加以讨论。
问题部分的每一个断言都应该有论据支撑。没有支撑的主张——"Most people agree that..." 或 "It is obvious that..."——会削弱你的可信度。
夸大问题的严重程度可能会适得其反。如果读者发现你在夸大,他们就会怀疑你写的其他一切。如实地呈现论据,即使数字没有你希望的那么惊人。
| 维度 | 它回答的问题 |
|---|---|
| 性质 | 问题究竟是什么? |
| 范围 | 它有多普遍? |
| 重要性 | 它为什么重要? |
| 紧迫性 | 为什么必须现在行动? |
| 利益相关方 | 谁受到影响? |
| 技巧 | 目的 |
|---|---|
| 统计数据与数据 | 确立规模和严重程度 |
| 专家证词 | 建立可信度 |
| 案例研究与轶事 | 建立情感联系 |
| 根本原因分析 | 超越症状、找到原因 |
| 「数据—故事—数据」三明治 | 平衡逻辑与情感 |
约10分钟阅读
界定问题只完成了一半的工作。解决方案部分,是你证明自己能从诊断走向行动的地方。一个有力的解决方案,并不只是一个听起来不错的想法——它是一个具体、可行、以论据为基础,并能回应可能的反对意见的提议。本节讲解评估解决方案的标准、有说服力地呈现解决方案的策略,以及回应反方意见和局限的技巧。
并非所有解决方案都一样好。动笔之前,先用五条标准来评估你所提出的解决方案:
解决方案必须针对问题部分所描述的具体原因或后果。这看起来理所当然,却是问题—解决型写作中最常见的失误之一:作者描述了一个问题,提出的解决方案针对的却是另一个(尽管相关的)问题。
不匹配:
Problem: Rural hospitals are closing because they cannot attract enough doctors.
Solution: Increase funding for medical research at universities.
这个解决方案针对的是医学进步,而不是农村地区的医生招聘。
匹配:
Problem: Rural hospitals are closing because they cannot attract enough doctors.
Solution: Establish loan forgiveness programs that cancel medical school debt for doctors who commit to practicing in underserved rural areas for at least five years.
这个解决方案通过消除一个经济障碍,直接针对了招聘问题。
检验: 写完解决方案后,重读你的问题部分。对你找出的每一个原因,都检查一下解决方案是否针对了它。如果主要的原因没有得到处理,你的解决方案就不完整。
解决方案必须切合实际。不切实际的提议,无论理论上听起来多么吸引人,读者都会拒绝。
可行性有好几个维度:
| 维度 | 问题 |
|---|---|
| 经济 | 能筹到资金吗?谁来买单? |
| 技术 | 相应的技术或专业知识存在吗? |
| 政治 | 有足够的支持吗?谁会反对? |
| 后勤 | 能在合理的时间内实施吗? |
| 法律 | 它符合现行法律吗?还是需要修改法律? |
| 文化 | 受影响的人群会接受它吗? |
在一篇短文中,你不需要涉及每一个维度,但应该承认其中最相关的几个。如果你的方案很昂贵,就解释资金从哪里来;如果它需要公众的支持,就解释人们为什么会支持它。
例:
"The program would cost approximately $50 million over five years -- a significant investment. However, the Centers for Disease Control estimates that the current problem costs the healthcare system $4.3 billion annually. Even a modest 10% reduction in that cost would save $430 million per year, producing a return on investment of more than 8:1 within the first five years."
这种成本效益的推理,让解决方案显得负责任、经过深思熟虑。
只要可能,就用证明它行之有效的论据来支撑你的解决方案。论据可以来自:
解决方案应该与问题相称。一个小小的不便,不值得来一场大规模的政策改革;一场系统性的危机,也不可能靠一个小小的调整来解决。
| 问题的规模 | 相称的解决方案规模 |
|---|---|
| 一个班级的问题 | 教师层面的干预 |
| 一所学校的问题 | 行政上的政策改变 |
| 一个社区的问题 | 地方政府的行动或社区项目 |
| 一个国家的问题 | 联邦立法、大规模的项目 |
| 一个全球的问题 | 国际合作、系统性的改革 |
为了解决一个街区的垃圾问题而提议召开一次全球峰会,是不相称的;为了应对全球气候变化而提议搞一次街区清洁日,是不够的。要让解决方案的规模与问题的规模相匹配。
每一个解决方案都可能带来意外的后果。优秀的作者会承认这些后果,并解释怎样加以缓解。
例:
"One potential risk of automated content moderation is over-censorship -- legitimate speech being flagged and removed by algorithms that cannot distinguish between harmful content and legitimate discussion of sensitive topics. To mitigate this risk, the proposed system includes a human review process for all flagged content and a straightforward appeals mechanism for users whose posts are removed."
承认风险不会削弱你的论证——相反,它表明你认真考虑过后果,从而加强了你的论证。
一旦你有了一个符合上述标准的解决方案,就需要清楚、有说服力地把它呈现出来。
呈现任何解决方案都适用的一个可靠结构:
WHAT: Cities should implement congestion pricing -- charging drivers a fee to enter high-traffic zones during peak hours.
HOW: Using existing electronic toll technology, cities can create designated zones (typically downtown cores) where drivers are charged $5-$15 during peak commuting hours (7-10 AM and 4-7 PM). Revenue collected would be dedicated exclusively to public transit improvements. The system would be phased in over 18 months, beginning with a lower fee that gradually increases.
WHY: Congestion pricing has been successfully implemented in London, Stockholm, and Singapore. In London, traffic entering the congestion zone decreased by 33% within the first year, bus speeds increased by 6%, and the program generated over $200 million annually for transit investment. Stockholm saw a 22% reduction in traffic and a measurable improvement in air quality.
当你的文章评估几个可能的解决方案时,要系统地呈现每一个,然后加以比较。
对每个解决方案,都要涉及:
然后加以比较:
| 标准 | 方案 A | 方案 B | 方案 C |
|---|---|---|---|
| 有效性 | 高 | 中等 | 高 |
| 成本 | $$$$ | $$ | $$$ |
| 实施时间 | 5 年 | 1 年 | 3 年 |
| 政治上的可行性 | 低 | 高 | 中等 |
| 产生意外后果的风险 | 中等 | 低 | 低 |
比较之后,说出你的推荐并说明理由:"While Solution A is the most effective in theory, its high cost and low political feasibility make it unlikely to succeed. Solution C offers the best balance of effectiveness, affordability, and political viability."
有力的问题—解决型写作不会无视反对的声音——它会直接面对。如果读者觉得作者只考虑了论证的一个方面,就会心存怀疑。
处理反对意见最有效的技巧,是「让步—反驳」(concession-rebuttal)模式:
让步: "Critics of congestion pricing argue, with some justification, that it places a disproportionate burden on low-income drivers who cannot afford the fees and may not have viable public transit alternatives."
反驳: "This concern is valid and must be addressed in the program's design. Successful implementations in London and Stockholm include exemptions for low-income residents, discounted rates for off-peak travel, and dedicated funding for bus and rail improvements in underserved neighborhoods. The key is not to abandon congestion pricing because of equity concerns, but to design the program so that equity is built into its structure."
这种方法远比无视或打发反对意见更有说服力。读者看到,你已经与反对你立场的最有力的论证交锋,却依然能为自己的立场辩护。
无论你的具体话题是什么,某些反对意见在问题—解决型写作中都会经常出现:
| 反对意见的类型 | 例子 | 回应策略 |
|---|---|---|
| 太昂贵 | 「我们负担不起这个项目」 | 给出成本效益分析,与不作为的代价相比较 |
| 行不通 | 「以前试过,失败了」 | 解释这次有什么不同,引用成功的例子 |
| 政府越权 | 「这会给政府太大的权力」 | 强调自愿的成分、日落条款和监督机制 |
| 意外后果 | 「这会带来新的问题」 | 承认风险,解释防范措施 |
| 不关我的事 | 「这是别人的问题」 | 说明这个问题怎样直接影响读者 |
| 滑坡 | 「如果我们这样做,会导致更糟的事情」 | 把你的具体提议与那种极端的情景区分开来 |
从问题部分到解决方案部分的过渡,是文章中最重要的时刻之一。读者需要感到解决方案是从问题中自然引出的——而不是作者突然换了一个话题。
让过渡顺畅的技巧:
很多问题—解决型文章以一个行动呼吁(call to action)结尾——直接呼吁读者去做某件具体的事。一个有力的行动呼吁是:
| 较弱的行动呼吁 | 较强的行动呼吁 |
|---|---|
| We should all do our part. | Contact your city council representative and urge them to support the proposed transit funding measure on the November ballot. |
| Awareness is the first step. | Before your next grocery trip, download the FoodKeeper app to learn which expiration dates are safety-based and which are merely quality suggestions -- and stop throwing away food that is still safe to eat. |
| Something needs to change. | If you are a hiring manager, commit to removing degree requirements from at least one job posting this quarter and evaluating candidates based on demonstrated skills instead. |
| 标准 | 问题 |
|---|---|
| 针对问题 | 它针对的是问题部分找出的那些原因吗? |
| 可行性 | 它能切实地得到实施吗? |
| 论据 | 有证据表明这种做法行之有效吗? |
| 相称性 | 它的规模与问题相称吗? |
| 意外后果 | 可能的风险是否得到了考虑和缓解? |
| 技巧 | 目的 |
|---|---|
| WHAT-HOW-WHY | 清楚地呈现解决方案的结构 |
| 让步—反驳 | 有说服力地处理反对意见 |
| 成本效益分析 | 证明经济上的可行性 |
| 先例论据 | 表明这个方案以前奏效过 |
| 具体的行动呼吁 | 让读者从理解走向行动 |
约9分钟阅读
理论和准则必不可少,但真正掌握问题—解决型写作最有效的方法,是研究真实的例子。本节提供修改前后的完整文章,以及不同领域的例子,展示前面几节的原则在实践中是怎样运作的。每个例子后面都附有分析,解释哪些地方管用、哪些地方不管用,以及为什么。
下面是一篇问题—解决型文章,作者了解基本的结构,但还没有掌握有效界定问题和展开解决方案的技巧。
Title: The Problem of Food Waste
Food waste is a big problem in the world today. A lot of food is thrown away every day by restaurants, supermarkets, and regular people. This is bad for the environment and also means that some people go hungry while others waste food.
There are many reasons for food waste. People buy too much food and then do not eat it all. Restaurants make more food than they can sell. Supermarkets throw away food that does not look perfect. These are all causes of the problem.
The solution to food waste is to reduce it. People should buy less food and plan their meals better. Restaurants should donate leftover food to shelters. Supermarkets should sell imperfect produce at a discount instead of throwing it away. The government should also create laws to prevent food waste.
In conclusion, food waste is a serious problem that affects the environment and contributes to hunger. If everyone does their part, we can reduce food waste and make the world a better place.
| 问题 | 解释 |
|---|---|
| 问题界定含糊 | "A lot of food" 和 "big problem" 都不具体。没有数据,没有规模。 |
| 没有论据 | 每一个主张都是没有支撑的断言。没有统计数据、研究或例子。 |
| 没有指出利益相关方 | 具体是谁受到影响?在哪里?有多严重? |
| 没有紧迫感 | 读者完全感受不到这个问题为什么现在就需要关注。 |
| 泛泛的解决方案 | "People should buy less food" 和 "the government should create laws" 太宽泛,无法执行。 |
| 没有讨论可行性 | 这些解决方案怎样实施?要花多少钱?谁来负责? |
| 解决方案没有论据 | 没有引用任何先例、试点项目或专家的认可。 |
| 没有反方意见 | 完全无视了可能的反对意见。 |
| 结论软弱 | "If everyone does their part" 是一句毫无新意的陈词滥调。 |
下面是同一篇文章,经过改写后有了具体的论据、清楚的问题界定、一个可行且有论据支撑的解决方案,以及对反方意见的处理。
Title: Reducing Commercial Food Waste Through Mandatory Donation Laws
Each year, approximately 1.3 billion tons of food produced for human consumption is lost or wasted globally -- roughly one-third of all food produced. In the United States alone, an estimated 80 million tons of food are discarded annually, accounting for 22% of all material in landfills and generating 170 million metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent in greenhouse gas emissions. Meanwhile, 44 million Americans -- including 13 million children -- experience food insecurity. The coexistence of massive waste and widespread hunger is not merely inefficient; it represents a systemic failure that demands a structural solution.
The largest single source of food waste in the United States is not households but the commercial sector: restaurants, grocery stores, and food service operations. According to the nonprofit ReFED, commercial food waste accounts for approximately 40% of all food waste nationally. The primary drivers are overproduction (restaurants and caterers prepare more food than is consumed to ensure availability), cosmetic standards (retailers reject produce with minor blemishes that do not affect taste or nutrition), and confusion about date labels ("sell by," "best by," and "use by" dates are not federally regulated and do not indicate food safety, yet both retailers and consumers treat them as expiration dates). Collectively, commercial businesses discard an estimated 35 million tons of edible food each year -- food that could feed people in need but instead generates methane as it decomposes in landfills.
The most effective policy intervention is a mandatory commercial food donation law. Under such a law, commercial food businesses above a certain size threshold would be required to donate edible surplus food to registered food banks and charitable organizations rather than sending it to landfills. France enacted such a law in 2016, requiring all supermarkets larger than 400 square meters to sign donation agreements with food charities. In the first three years, food donations from supermarkets increased by 22%, and the amount of edible food sent to landfills decreased by an estimated 15%. Italy passed similar legislation in the same year, using a tax incentive model rather than a mandate, and saw a 20% increase in commercial food donations.
Implementation in the United States would build on existing infrastructure. The Feeding America network already operates 200 food banks and 60,000 food pantries nationwide, with established logistics for collecting, storing, and distributing donated food. The federal Bill Emerson Good Samaritan Food Donation Act already protects food donors from civil and criminal liability, removing the legal barrier that businesses most frequently cite as a reason for not donating. What is missing is the mandate. A phased approach -- beginning with large grocery chains and restaurant groups, then expanding to mid-size businesses over three years -- would allow the donation infrastructure to scale gradually. Estimated costs for businesses would be minimal, as most would simply redirect food already being handled for disposal, and the donation would qualify for enhanced tax deductions.
Critics of mandatory donation laws raise two primary objections. First, they argue that the policy imposes an unfair regulatory burden on businesses. This concern is legitimate but overstated: the French experience shows that compliance costs for supermarkets averaged less than 0.5% of operating budgets, and many businesses reported that donation logistics were simpler than waste disposal logistics. Second, critics worry that food banks lack the capacity to handle a sudden increase in donations. This is a valid operational concern, which is why the phased implementation timeline is essential. The three-year rollout allows food banks to expand refrigeration, transportation, and volunteer infrastructure in step with increasing donation volume. Federal grants from the USDA Community Food Projects program could fund this expansion at an estimated cost of $200 million -- a modest investment compared to the $218 billion annual economic value of the food currently wasted.
The structural mismatch between commercial food waste and food insecurity is both unnecessary and solvable. France and Italy have demonstrated that mandatory or incentivized donation laws meaningfully redirect edible food from landfills to people who need it. The United States has the legal framework, the charitable infrastructure, and the economic incentive to do the same. What it lacks is the political will to require action rather than merely hope for it. Passing a federal mandatory donation law would be the most impactful single policy change the country could make to reduce food waste, lower greenhouse emissions, and feed millions of hungry Americans.
| 要素 | 较弱的版本 | 较强的版本 |
|---|---|---|
| 问题的具体程度 | "A lot of food is thrown away" | "80 million tons annually; 22% of landfill material" |
| 论据 | 没有 | 来自 USDA、ReFED 的统计数据;通篇都有具体的数字 |
| 根本原因分析 | "People buy too much" | 商业上的过量生产、外观标准、对日期标签的混淆 |
| 利益相关方 | 含糊("some people go hungry") | "44 million Americans, including 13 million children" |
| 解决方案的具体程度 | "Restaurants should donate leftovers" | 分阶段实施的强制性商业捐赠法 |
| 解决方案的论据 | 没有 | 法国和意大利的先例及其具体结果 |
| 可行性 | 没有涉及 | 现有的基础设施(Feeding America)、法律保护、成本估算 |
| 反方意见 | 没有涉及 | 承认并反驳了两个反对意见 |
| 行动呼吁 | "Everyone should do their part" | 带有具体政策机制的联邦立法 |
问题: 低收入城区的高中辍学率。
问题段:
In the 50 largest urban school districts in the United States, the average graduation rate is 68% -- 17 percentage points below the national average. In some districts, fewer than half of students who enter ninth grade earn a diploma within four years. The consequences extend far beyond individual students. Adults without a high school diploma earn an average of $10,000 less per year than graduates, are three times more likely to be unemployed, and are eight times more likely to be incarcerated. Over a lifetime, each dropout costs taxpayers an estimated $292,000 in lower tax revenue and higher spending on public assistance, healthcare, and criminal justice.
解决方案段:
Early warning intervention systems can identify students at risk of dropping out as early as sixth grade by tracking three key indicators: attendance below 90%, failure in a core academic subject, and a behavior referral. The ABC (Attendance-Behavior-Coursework) system, developed by researchers at Johns Hopkins University, has been implemented in over 1,000 schools nationwide. In Philadelphia, schools using the ABC system reduced their dropout rate by 42% over five years by assigning at-risk students to dedicated mentors who met with them weekly, connected their families with social services, and coordinated with teachers to address academic struggles before they became insurmountable.
问题: 抗生素耐药性。
问题段:
Antibiotic-resistant infections kill an estimated 1.27 million people worldwide each year -- more than HIV/AIDS or malaria. If current trends continue, drug-resistant infections are projected to cause 10 million deaths annually by 2050, surpassing cancer as a leading cause of death globally. The primary driver is overuse: approximately 30% of all antibiotics prescribed in outpatient settings in the United States are unnecessary, and 80% of all antibiotics sold in the country are used in livestock agriculture, not to treat sick animals but to promote growth and prevent disease in crowded feedlot conditions.
解决方案段:
A three-pronged strategy is needed. First, implementing mandatory antibiotic stewardship programs in all hospitals and outpatient clinics, requiring physicians to justify prescriptions against evidence-based guidelines. Sweden's stewardship program reduced unnecessary prescriptions by 43% over a decade without adverse patient outcomes. Second, banning the use of medically important antibiotics in livestock for non-therapeutic purposes, as Denmark did in 1998 -- a policy that reduced agricultural antibiotic use by 50% with no measurable impact on farming productivity. Third, funding the development of new antibiotics through a subscription-based "Netflix model," in which governments pay pharmaceutical companies a fixed annual fee for access to new drugs, decoupling profit from sales volume and removing the incentive to promote overuse.
问题: 数字虚假信息。
问题段:
A 2023 study published in Science found that false news stories on social media platforms spread six times faster than true stories and reach significantly larger audiences. During major elections, public health crises, and natural disasters, misinformation can cause measurable harm: vaccine misinformation has been linked to a 5-10% reduction in vaccination rates in communities with high social media usage, and false election information has been shown to reduce voter turnout among targeted demographics.
解决方案段:
Platforms should be required to implement "friction" interventions -- small design changes that slow the spread of unverified content. Research from MIT demonstrates that simply asking users "Is this headline accurate?" before they share an article reduces the sharing of misinformation by 20%. Adding a brief delay before resharing flagged content reduces viral spread by an additional 15%. These interventions do not censor content or require platforms to determine what is "true" -- they simply introduce a moment of reflection into a process currently designed for maximum speed. Taiwan's "humor over rumor" initiative, which partners with civic tech organizations to rapidly produce fact-checked responses to viral misinformation, reduced the spread of election-related false claims by 30% during its 2020 elections.
问题: 远程办公环境中的员工职业倦怠。
问题段:
A 2023 Gallup survey found that 67% of remote workers reported feeling burned out at least sometimes, with 23% reporting burnout "very often" or "always." The primary drivers are the dissolution of work-life boundaries (remote workers log an average of 2.5 additional hours per day compared to office workers), social isolation (particularly among employees who live alone), and the phenomenon of "Zoom fatigue" -- the cognitive overload caused by back-to-back video meetings that demand constant visual attention and self-monitoring.
解决方案段:
Companies should implement a structured "right to disconnect" policy modeled on France's 2017 labor law, which prohibits employers from requiring employees to respond to communications outside of defined working hours. Internally, this means establishing clear "core hours" (e.g., 10 AM to 3 PM) during which meetings and synchronous communication are expected, with all other hours designated as flexible, asynchronous work time. Shopify's 2023 "calendar purge" -- in which the company eliminated all recurring meetings with more than two attendees and required managers to justify any new meeting -- resulted in a 33% reduction in meeting time and a measurable improvement in employee satisfaction scores.
纵观全部四个领域,注意以下这些规律:
| 规律 | 表现 |
|---|---|
| 具体的数据 | 每个问题段都至少包含两个量化的事实 |
| 具名的来源 | 统计数据都注明了具体的机构或研究 |
| 找出根本原因 | 每个问题都超越了症状,找到了原因 |
| 以先例为基础的解决方案 | 每个解决方案都引用了一个有结果的现实实施案例 |
| 解释机制 | 解决方案解释了它们怎样以及为什么起作用,而不只是提议什么 |
| 相称的应对 | 每个解决方案都与其问题的规模和性质相匹配 |
这些规律并非巧合。它们反映了有说服力的问题—解决型写作的基本要求:具体、有论据,以及问题与所提出的应对之间的逻辑一致性。
| 课程内容 | 要点 |
|---|---|
| 修改前后对比 | 具体性、论据和对反方意见的处理,能把一篇较弱的文章变成一篇较强的文章 |
| 不同领域的例子 | 同样的原则适用于教育、公共卫生、科技和商业 |
| 一致的规律 | 数据、来源、根本原因、先例和对机制的解释,出现在每一个较强的例子中 |
| 练习策略 | 研究较强的例子,然后把同样的技巧运用到你自己的话题上 |
约8分钟阅读
本节提供起草和修改问题—解决型文章时可以使用的模板、信号短语、组织模式和检查清单。把这一节收藏起来,每当你需要一个结构框架、一个过渡短语,或者对文章进行质量检查时,都可以回来查阅。
当你只有一个主要的解决方案、而问题需要详细解释读者才能体会到方案的价值时,使用这个模板。
| 部分 | 段落 | 内容 |
|---|---|---|
| 引言 | 1 | 引子 + 背景 + 论点句(说明问题并预告解决方案) |
| 问题 | 2 | 问题的性质和范围(它是什么、有多普遍) |
| 问题 | 3 | 原因和根本因素(它为什么存在) |
| 问题 | 4 | 影响和后果(谁受到影响、不加处理会怎样) |
| 解决方案 | 5 | 对解决方案的描述(它是什么 WHAT、怎样起作用 HOW) |
| 解决方案 | 6 | 有效性的论据(先例、研究、专家的支持) |
| 解决方案 | 7 | 可行性与实施(成本、时间表、负责方) |
| 反方意见 | 8 | 承认并反驳反对意见 |
| 结论 | 9 | 总结 + 行动呼吁 |
当问题有多个不同的方面、每个方面都需要各自有针对性的解决方案时,使用这个模板。
| 部分 | 段落 | 内容 |
|---|---|---|
| 引言 | 1 | 引子 + 背景 + 论点句 |
| 方面 A | 2–3 | 描述问题的方面 A + 针对方面 A 的解决方案 |
| 方面 B | 4–5 | 描述问题的方面 B + 针对方面 B 的解决方案 |
| 方面 C | 6–7 | 描述问题的方面 C + 针对方面 C 的解决方案 |
| 整合 | 8 | 这些解决方案怎样作为一个综合方案协同起作用 |
| 结论 | 9 | 总结 + 行动呼吁 |
当你在比较几个可能的解决方案、并推荐其中一个时,使用这个模板。
| 部分 | 段落 | 内容 |
|---|---|---|
| 引言 | 1 | 引子 + 背景 + 论点句(表明将评估多个方案) |
| 问题 | 2–3 | 完整的问题描述(性质、范围、原因、影响) |
| 方案 A | 4 | 描述、论据、优点、缺点 |
| 方案 B | 5 | 描述、论据、优点、缺点 |
| 方案 C | 6 | 描述、论据、优点、缺点 |
| 比较 | 7 | 并排评估 + 推荐及理由 |
| 结论 | 8 | 总结 + 行动呼吁 |
在标准化考试(IELTS Task 2、TOEFL)或需要简短的限时写作中,使用这个模板。
| 部分 | 段落 | 内容 |
|---|---|---|
| 引言 | 1 | 转述问题 + 同时说明问题和解决方案的论点句 |
| 问题 | 2 | 用 2–3 条论据界定问题 |
| 解决方案 | 3 | 提出解决方案,并给出论据和可行性 |
| 反方意见 | 4 | 承认一个反对意见并加以反驳 |
| 结论 | 5 | 重述论点句 + 行动呼吁 |
有效的问题—解决型写作依赖清楚的路标。用这些短语来引导读者跟上文章的逻辑推进。
| 目的 | 信号短语 |
|---|---|
| 说明问题存在 | One of the most pressing challenges facing... / A growing concern in... / A significant obstacle to... / The issue of... has reached critical proportions. |
| 确立范围 | According to [source], approximately... / Data from [organization] reveals that... / Across [region/industry/population], the rate of... has increased by... |
| 找出原因 | The primary drivers of this problem are... / This situation stems from... / Several interrelated factors contribute to... / At the root of this issue is... |
| 展示影响 | The consequences of inaction are severe. / This problem affects not only... but also... / If left unaddressed, this trend will... / The human cost of this failure is... |
| 营造紧迫感 | The window for effective intervention is narrowing. / Without immediate action... / Current projections indicate that by [year]... / The situation has deteriorated to the point where... |
| 目的 | 信号短语 |
|---|---|
| 桥接句 | Given the severity of this problem, a structural solution is needed. / Addressing the root causes identified above requires... / While the problem is complex, a practical and evidence-based solution exists. / Fortunately, there is a proven approach to addressing this challenge. |
| 标示转换 | The most effective response to this problem is... / To address these issues, [stakeholder] should... / A growing body of evidence supports... as the most promising intervention. / The solution lies in... |
| 目的 | 信号短语 |
|---|---|
| 描述解决方案 | The proposed solution involves... / Under this approach, [stakeholder] would... / The core of this proposal is... / Specifically, this solution requires three components. |
| 提供论据 | This approach has been successfully implemented in... / Research from [source] demonstrates that... / A [year] pilot program found that... / Experts in [field] have endorsed this approach because... |
| 解释可行性 | Implementation would proceed in [number] phases. / The estimated cost of... is offset by... / The necessary infrastructure already exists in the form of... / A phased rollout over [timeframe] would allow... |
| 目的 | 信号短语 |
|---|---|
| 承认反对意见 | Critics of this approach argue that... / A common objection is that... / Some may contend that... / It is true that... / Opponents raise legitimate concerns about... |
| 作出让步 | This concern is valid to a degree. / There is some merit to this argument. / Admittedly, the solution is not without risks. / It must be acknowledged that... |
| 进行反驳 | However, the evidence suggests otherwise. / Nevertheless, when weighed against the alternative... / This objection, while understandable, overlooks... / The concern is mitigated by... / Despite this limitation, the overall benefits outweigh the drawbacks because... |
| 目的 | 信号短语 |
|---|---|
| 总结 | In summary, the combination of... and... offers the most viable path forward. / The evidence presented demonstrates that... / Taken together, these measures would... |
| 行动呼吁 | It is time for [stakeholder] to act. / The first step is... / Policymakers should prioritize... / Every [reader type] can contribute by... / The choice is clear: we can continue to... or we can... |
| 最后的强调 | The cost of inaction far exceeds the cost of intervention. / This is not merely a policy question -- it is a moral imperative. / The tools and knowledge exist; what is needed now is the will to act. |
| 模式 | 最适合 | 结构 | 示例话题 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 分块式 | 单一方案;问题需要大量铺垫 | 先完整写问题,再完整写解决方案 | 强制性食物捐赠法 |
| 交替式 | 多层面的问题;每个方面都有针对性的解决办法 | 问题 A + 方案 A,问题 B + 方案 B…… | 城市的可持续发展(交通、能源、垃圾) |
| 多方案式 | 比较分析;政策评估 | 先写问题,再写方案 A、B、C,最后给出推荐 | 降低大学的费用 |
| 因果链式 | 有清楚因果顺序的问题 | 原因 1 导致结果 1,结果 1 又引发问题;解决方案打断这条链 | 抗生素耐药性的循环 |
| 按利益相关方 | 以不同方式影响多个群体的问题 | 利益相关方 A 的问题 + 解决方案,利益相关方 B 的问题 + 解决方案 | 医疗服务的可及性(患者、医疗服务提供者、保险公司) |
起草或修改文章的问题部分时,使用这份清单。
起草或修改文章的解决方案部分时,使用这份清单。
这张表汇总了阅卷人和评审者在问题—解决型写作中最常指出的弱点,以及每一种的改法。
| 错误 | 表现 | 怎么改 |
|---|---|---|
| 问题含糊 | "Many people are affected by this issue" | 换成具体的数据:"23 million Americans lack broadband access" |
| 没有根本原因 | 描述了问题的表面,却没有说明它为什么存在 | 运用「五个为什么」;找出结构性或系统性的原因 |
| 方案不匹配 | 问题讲的是 X,解决方案针对的却是 Y | 重读问题部分;确保每一个原因都有对应的回应 |
| 解决方案没有论据 | "This would probably work" | 引用一个先例、一项研究或专家的认可 |
| 忽视可行性 | 宏大的提议,却没有实施计划 | 加上成本估算、时间表、负责方和现有资源 |
| 没有反方意见 | 只呈现了作者的视角 | 至少加一组「让步—反驳」 |
| 结论软弱 | "In conclusion, this is an important issue" | 用新的措辞重述论点句,概括关键论据,给出具体的行动呼吁 |
| 问题部分原地打转 | 同一个主张在几个段落里换着说法重复 | 每个段落都应该讨论一个不同的维度(范围、原因、影响、紧迫性) |
| 有情感却没支撑 | 轶事多,数据少 | 加上统计数据和来源引用,来平衡情感上的感染 |
| 数据多却缺少人情味 | 全是统计数据,没有人的元素 | 加一个轶事或案例研究,让问题显得真实 |
当你不知道一个句子该怎样开头时,用这些句子开头作为起点。
提交之前,用这份评分标准来评估你自己的问题—解决型文章。
| 标准 | 优秀(5) | 良好(4) | 合格(3) | 有待提高(2) | 不合格(1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 问题的清晰度 | 具体、以论据为基础、多维度 | 清楚,论据充分 | 能看懂,但缺乏深度 | 含糊,论据很少 | 缺失或不连贯 |
| 根本原因分析 | 用论据找出了系统性的原因 | 清楚地找出了原因 | 提到了原因,但很肤浅 | 罗列的是症状,而不是原因 | 没有分析 |
| 解决方案的具体程度 | 详细、可执行,并有实施计划 | 清楚,大体可执行 | 能看懂,但细节含糊 | 泛泛或抽象 | 缺失或不切实际 |
| 解决方案的论据 | 多个先例,并有量化的结果 | 至少一个有力的先例 | 有一些支撑论据 | 只有断言,没有论据 | 没有论据 |
| 可行性 | 涉及了成本、时间表、资源和障碍 | 涵盖了可行性的大部分维度 | 有一些关于可行性的讨论 | 只是简单提到 | 没有涉及 |
| 反方意见 | 公正地陈述并反驳了多个反对意见 | 很好地处理了一个反对意见 | 提到了反对意见,但处理得很弱 | 打发了反对意见,却没有与之交锋 | 没有涉及 |
| 组织 | 逻辑流畅清楚,过渡有效 | 组织良好,有少许缺漏 | 遵循了基本结构 | 杂乱,但还能辨认 | 没有清楚的结构 |
| 论据的质量 | 多个来源、具体的数据、具名的权威 | 来源良好,大体具体 | 有一些论据,偶尔含糊 | 论据很少 | 没有论据 |
| 资源 | 用途 |
|---|---|
| 文章模板(4 种) | 为你的话题选择合适的组织结构 |
| 信号短语 | 用清楚、有目的的语言开始句子和段落 |
| 组织模式速查表 | 为你的话题找到最合适的结构方式 |
| 问题界定检查清单 | 确保你的问题部分完整而有说服力 |
| 解决方案评估检查清单 | 确保你的解决方案具体、可行、以论据为基础 |
| 常见的错误模式 | 诊断并改正初稿中的弱点 |
| 句子开头 | 在任何部分摆脱写不下去的困境 |
| 自我评估评分标准 | 在提交之前评估你的文章 |