约8分钟阅读
提纲是一篇文字的结构化计划。它组织你的观点,确定你呈现它们的顺序,并在你写成完整的段落之前,暴露出你推理中的漏洞。许多写作者跳过列提纲这一步,因为它感觉像是额外的工作,但事实恰恰相反:列提纲能节省时间、减少挫败感,并写出更有力的文章。本节解释列提纲为什么重要,并介绍可以用于任何写作任务的几种主要的列提纲方法。
不列提纲就写作,就像不画设计图就盖房子。你最后也许能盖出一个立得住的东西,但它几乎肯定会有结构上的问题——房间之间缺乏合乎逻辑的连通,墙不承重,门打开后通向虚无。列提纲,是在你添加血肉之前,先给你的文章搭好骨架。
1. 它能理清你的思路。
把观点组织成一个有层级的结构,这个行为本身就迫使你去决定:你的主要论证究竟是什么,哪些论点支撑它,这些论点之间又有什么关系。许多写作者只有在试着为自己的想法列提纲之后,才发现自己真正想说的是什么。如果你无法把自己的观点组织成一份提纲,这就说明你的思路还没有清晰到可以动笔的程度。
2. 它能预防结构上的问题。
文章中最常见的结构问题——段落重复同一个观点、论证的顺序不对、正文段落与论点句脱节、结论引入了新的论证——都是提纲能在它们被写进完整的文字之前就发现的问题。重新排列要点,比重组写好的段落容易得多。
3. 它能节省时间。
这有悖直觉,却一贯如此。列提纲的写作者花在文章上的总时间,比直接动笔起草的写作者更少。原因很简单:重组一份提纲只需要几分钟,重组一份草稿却要好几个小时。列提纲把思考放在了前面,这样起草就成了执行的问题,而不是摸索的问题。
4. 它能减少写作障碍。
写作障碍常常来自不知道接下来该写什么。提纲消除了这个问题。当你坐下来起草时,你不是盯着一张白纸、想着下一步写什么。你看着的是一份清楚的计划,它确切地告诉你这个段落需要完成什么。你的任务从「弄清楚要说什么」变成了「把这件具体的事说好」。
5. 它能暴露论证中的漏洞。
当你看到整个论证以提纲的形式铺展开来时,缺失的部分就会一目了然。你可能会意识到,你的第二个正文段落没有任何论据;或者你有三个关于成本的论点,却没有任何关于质量的论点;或者你的反方论证部分完全缺失。这些漏洞在一份简洁的提纲中,比在好几页的文字中更容易发现。
提纲分布在一条光谱上,从松散灵活到严格详细。两个极端都不总是最好的——合适的做法取决于作业、写作者,以及所处的写作阶段。
非正式提纲是一份快速、灵活的计划。它可能是一张项目符号清单、一幅思维导图、一组便利贴,或者在草稿纸上随手写下的几句话。没有任何格式上的规则。目标只是记下你的主要观点,并把它们大致排好顺序。
什么时候使用非正式提纲:
非正式提纲的例子:
Thesis: School uniforms do more harm than good.
- Suppress self-expression (identity development in adolescence)
- No proven academic benefit (cite studies)
- Financial burden on low-income families (costs, replacement)
- Counterargument: reduces bullying? But bullying shifts to other markers
这只花了 30 秒就写好了,却给了写作者一个清楚的方向。对于一篇限时考试作文来说,这就足够了。
正式提纲使用标准化的编号系统和一致的格式,来展示观点之间的层级关系。正式提纲用罗马数字、大写字母、阿拉伯数字和小写字母来表示不同的细节层级。
什么时候使用正式提纲:
标准的正式提纲格式:
I. Main point (Roman numeral)
A. Supporting point (capital letter)
1. Detail or evidence (Arabic numeral)
a. Sub-detail (lowercase letter)
每一级缩进代表一个具体程度的层级。主要论点最宽泛;次级细节最具体。
在正式提纲中,有两种截然不同的做法:使用简短短语的词组式提纲,以及使用完整句子的句子式提纲。
词组式提纲(topic outline)在每一个层级上都使用简短的短语或单个的词。它列起来更快,也更便于浏览。
I. Introduction
A. Hook: rising student debt statistics
B. Context: cost of higher education
C. Thesis: community colleges as undervalued alternative
II. Cost advantage
A. Average tuition comparison
B. Reduced student loan burden
C. Ability to work while studying
III. Academic quality
A. Transfer rates to four-year universities
B. Small class sizes
C. Industry-experienced instructors
IV. Career outcomes
A. Employment rates for graduates
B. Vocational and technical programs
C. Local employer partnerships
V. Conclusion
A. Restate thesis
B. Synthesize cost, quality, careers
C. Call to action: reduce stigma
优点: 写起来快,容易重新组织,适合头脑风暴。
缺点: 短语可能有歧义。"Transfer rates to four-year universities" 并没有告诉你,你论证的是转学率很高(支持你的论点),还是很低(削弱你的论点)。
句子式提纲(sentence outline)在每一个层级上都使用完整的句子。每一条都确切地说明文章的这一部分将要说什么。
I. Community colleges are a significantly undervalued pathway to
higher education that deserves greater public investment and
cultural respect.
A. The average American student now graduates with over $30,000
in student loan debt.
B. Despite rising costs, alternatives to four-year universities
remain stigmatized.
C. Thesis: Community colleges offer comparable academic quality
at a fraction of the cost, with strong career outcomes that
challenge the assumption that a four-year degree is the only
path to professional success.
II. Community colleges cost a fraction of what four-year universities
charge, dramatically reducing the financial burden on students.
A. Average annual tuition at a community college is $3,800,
compared to $10,700 for in-state public universities.
B. Students who complete two years at a community college before
transferring save an average of $14,000 in total education costs.
C. The lower cost allows most community college students to work
part-time and graduate with little or no debt.
优点: 消除了歧义。每个论点都得到了充分的表述。这份提纲几乎就替你把文章写好了——起草只是把句子扩展成段落。
缺点: 列起来要花多得多的时间。可能会显得僵硬,也可能会妨碍写作者在起草过程中发现新的想法。
| 情境 | 建议的做法 |
|---|---|
| 限时考试(规划时间有限) | 非正式提纲或词组式提纲 |
| 短文(1000 词以下) | 词组式提纲 |
| 研究论文(1500 词以上) | 句子式提纲 |
| 复杂或不熟悉的话题 | 句子式提纲 |
| 合作写作项目 | 句子式提纲 |
| 头脑风暴阶段 | 先列非正式提纲,再使之正式化 |
许多写作者在头脑风暴时先列一份词组式提纲,然后在起草之前把关键的部分转换成句子式提纲。这种两阶段的做法兼顾了速度和精确。
反向提纲是一种修改技巧。你不是在写作之前列提纲,而是根据一份已经存在的草稿列出提纲。这种技巧能帮你诊断已经写好的文字中的结构问题。
| 发现的问题 | 它在反向提纲中的表现 |
|---|---|
| 观点重复 | 两条或更多的提纲条目说的基本上是同一件事 |
| 缺少逻辑环节 | 条目之间有一个空缺,那里本该有一个起连接作用的观点 |
| 离题的段落 | 一条与论点句无关的条目 |
| 顺序错误 | 一条放在更前面或更后面会更合理的条目 |
| 段落承担得太多 | 一条需要两三个句子才能概括的条目 |
| 论点展开不足 | 一条含糊或缺乏实质内容的条目 |
假设你为一篇关于可再生能源的文章列了反向提纲,得到了这样的结果:
1. Introduction: Renewable energy is important.
2. Solar energy is becoming cheaper.
3. Wind farms create jobs.
4. Some people oppose renewable energy.
5. Solar panels are made of silicon.
6. Germany has invested heavily in renewables.
7. Nuclear energy is also low-carbon.
8. Conclusion: We should invest in renewables.
现在问题一目了然了:
有了反向提纲,这个诊断只需要两分钟。没有它,你可能会逐句修改好几个小时,却始终看不到结构上的问题。
你拥有的时间,决定了你的提纲应该有多详细。
写下你的论点句,列出主要论点。仅此而已。
Thesis: Public transport > cars for cities
- Cost to individuals
- Environment
- Traffic/urban planning
列一份包含主要论点和关键论据的词组式提纲。
I. Intro: Cities should invest in public transport
II. Cost: avg car ownership $9,000/yr vs transit pass $1,200/yr
III. Environment: emissions per passenger mile comparison
IV. Urban planning: parking lots vs green space
V. Counter: rural areas different, but essay focuses on cities
VI. Conclusion: economic and environmental case is clear
列一份完整的句子式提纲,并把论据对应到每个部分。这可能要花一到三个小时,但在起草时会节省多得多的时间。
| 概念 | 要点 |
|---|---|
| 为什么要列提纲 | 理清思路、预防结构问题、节省时间、减少写作障碍、暴露漏洞 |
| 非正式提纲 | 快速、灵活,适合限时考试和短文 |
| 正式提纲 | 有层级的编号,适合研究论文和复杂的论证 |
| 词组式提纲 | 使用短语,列起来快,可能有歧义 |
| 句子式提纲 | 使用完整的句子,消除歧义,列起来较慢 |
| 反向提纲 | 根据现有的草稿列出,诊断结构问题 |
| 按时间选择做法 | 让提纲的详细程度与可用的规划时间相匹配 |
约8分钟阅读
在理论上理解列提纲是一回事。用它来写出更好的文字,则是另一回事。本节逐一讲解不同文章类型的完整提纲示例,展示怎样把提纲变成草稿,并演示基于提纲的修改怎样把一篇组织混乱的文章变成一篇连贯的文章。
题目: Some people believe that universities should focus on providing academic skills, while others think they should prepare students for employment. Discuss both views and give your opinion.
规划时间: 5 分钟
Thesis: Universities should primarily teach academic skills but
incorporate practical employment preparation.
Body 1: Academic skills view
- Critical thinking, research, analysis = foundation for all careers
- Knowledge changes; skills to learn are permanent
- Example: philosophy graduates -- high employability despite
"impractical" degree
Body 2: Employment preparation view
- Graduates face competitive job market
- Employers report skills gap (communication, teamwork, tech)
- Example: engineering programs with industry placements
Body 3: My view -- balance is best
- Academic core + applied components
- Internships, case studies, guest lectures from industry
- Example: medical schools blend theory and practice successfully
Conclusion: Neither extreme works; integration is the answer.
这份提纲大约用了四分钟。注意它是一份非正式的词组式提纲,适合限时考试的条件。每个正文段落都有一个清楚的主张、支撑的推理和一个具体的例子。
题目: Analyze how the author uses rhetorical strategies to build an argument about the importance of public libraries.
规划时间: 15 分钟
I. Introduction
A. The author builds a layered argument that moves from
emotional appeal to logical evidence to moral imperative.
B. Thesis: Through strategic use of pathos, logos, and a
carefully timed ethical appeal, the author constructs an
argument that makes cutting library funding feel not just
unwise but morally indefensible.
II. Pathos: Emotional foundation (paragraphs 1-3 of source)
A. Opens with anecdote of elderly man learning to read at 74
1. Specific sensory details create empathy
2. Reader identifies with human desire for knowledge
B. Contrasts individual story with impersonal budget statistics
1. The human face makes abstract cuts feel personal
C. Effect: Reader is emotionally invested before the argument
becomes analytical
III. Logos: Logical evidence (paragraphs 4-7 of source)
A. Shifts to data after emotional groundwork
1. Library usage statistics (visits, programs, digital access)
2. Cost-benefit analysis ($1 invested = $5.50 returned)
B. Anticipates and refutes counterarguments
1. "Libraries are obsolete" -- addresses with digital divide data
2. "Private sector can fill the gap" -- addresses with rural access
C. Effect: Reader now has rational justification for the
emotional response established earlier
IV. Ethos: Moral imperative (paragraphs 8-9 of source)
A. Final paragraphs invoke democratic values
1. Libraries as the embodiment of equal access
2. Allusion to Carnegie and the public good tradition
B. Positions library funding as a moral test, not a budget line
C. Effect: Cutting funding becomes not just foolish but ethically
wrong
V. Conclusion
A. The three-stage strategy is deliberate: feel, think, then
judge
B. By the end, opposing the author feels like opposing literacy,
democracy, and basic human dignity
C. The argument's power lies in its sequencing, not just its
individual elements
这是一份适合较长分析性文章的正式句子式提纲。每个部分不仅说明作者将要讨论什么,还说明作者将就它提出什么论证。
任务: 建议公司是否应该进军东南亚市场。
I. Executive Summary
- Recommend expansion into Vietnam and Thailand
- Projected ROI: 18% within 3 years
- Key risk: regulatory complexity
II. Market Analysis
A. Market size and growth projections
- Vietnam: GDP growth 6.5%, young population, rising middle class
- Thailand: established consumer market, strong digital infrastructure
B. Competitive landscape
- Few direct competitors in our niche
- Local incumbents lack our technology advantage
C. Consumer behavior
- Mobile-first purchasing patterns
- Brand loyalty still developing = opportunity for early movers
III. Risk Assessment
A. Regulatory risks
- Vietnam: foreign ownership restrictions in certain sectors
- Thailand: data localization requirements
B. Operational risks
- Supply chain complexity
- Talent acquisition in local markets
C. Financial risks
- Currency fluctuation
- Longer-than-expected path to profitability
IV. Recommendation
A. Phase 1: Thailand (lower regulatory barriers, test operations)
B. Phase 2: Vietnam (higher growth potential, enter after
learning from Phase 1)
C. Budget: $2.4M initial investment
D. Timeline: 18 months to Phase 1 launch
V. Conclusion
- Strategic alignment with company growth targets
- Manageable risk with phased approach
- Request board approval to proceed with Phase 1 planning
这份提纲说明,列提纲并不只适用于学术文章。商务写作也能从有条理的规划中获益良多,尤其是当文件需要为决策提供指导的时候。
从提纲到草稿的过渡,是许多写作者感到吃力的地方。他们有一份扎实的计划,却不知道怎样把要点扩展成流畅的段落。下面是一个系统的方法。
你提纲中的主要论点(罗马数字或最高一级的要点),就是你各个段落的主题句。
提纲条目: II. Cost advantage: avg car ownership $9,000/yr vs transit pass $1,200/yr
主题句: The most immediate financial argument for public transportation is the dramatic difference in cost between car ownership and transit ridership.
你提纲中的次级论点,就是每个段落中的论据和分析。
提纲中的次级论点:
扩展后的段落:
The most immediate financial argument for public transportation is the dramatic difference in cost between car ownership and transit ridership. According to the American Automobile Association, the average American spends approximately $9,000 per year on car-related expenses, including loan payments, insurance, fuel, maintenance, and parking. By contrast, the average annual cost of a public transit pass in a major U.S. city is roughly $1,200. This means that a household that replaces one car with a transit pass saves nearly $7,800 per year -- enough to cover three months of rent in many cities or to fund a year of community college tuition. For low-income families, this difference is not a minor convenience but a meaningful pathway to financial stability.
你的提纲告诉你接下来是什么,所以你可以写出连接段落的过渡语。
成本段的结尾,向前衔接环境段:
Beyond the personal financial benefits, shifting from cars to public transit yields significant environmental dividends.
许多写作者发现,在起草完正文之后再写引言更容易,因为到那时他们已经确切地知道文章论证的是什么。如果你在列提纲时写了引言,就在正文完成之后修改它,确保前后一致。
这个例子展示了反向提纲和重新组织怎样挽救一篇组织混乱的文章。
一个学生写了一篇文章,主张推迟上课时间。下面是其草稿的反向提纲:
1. Introduction: Teenagers are tired. Schools start too early.
2. Sleep science: adolescent circadian rhythms shift later in puberty.
3. My personal experience: I am always tired in first period.
4. Some schools have changed start times.
5. Counterargument: parents need early start for work schedules.
6. Sleep deprivation causes car accidents in teen drivers.
7. Academic performance improves with later start times.
8. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends starting after 8:30 AM.
9. Athletes perform better when well-rested.
10. Conclusion: Schools should start later.
反向提纲揭示出几个问题:
诊断之后,这个学生重新组织了文章:
I. Introduction
A. Hook: use personal experience briefly ("Like millions of
teenagers, I have sat through first period barely able to
keep my eyes open.")
B. Context: the AAP recommends starting after 8:30 AM; most
schools start before 8:00 AM.
C. Thesis: Pushing school start times to 8:30 AM or later
would improve academic performance, reduce teen car
accidents, and support adolescent health, with minimal
disruption to family schedules.
II. The science: why teenagers need later start times
A. Circadian rhythm shift during puberty
B. Biological inability to fall asleep before 11 PM
C. 8-10 hours of sleep recommended; early starts make this
impossible
III. The benefits: what later start times achieve
A. Academic performance: studies show grade improvements
B. Safety: reduction in drowsy-driving accidents
C. Health: lower rates of depression, obesity
D. Athletic performance improvement (brief mention)
IV. Real-world evidence: schools that have already changed
A. Seattle school district: 34 minutes later, 4.5% grade
increase
B. California statewide policy (2022): early results
V. Counterargument and rebuttal
A. Parent schedules disrupted -- but after-school programs
and staggered schedules address this
B. Bus scheduling costs -- but reduced healthcare and accident
costs offset this
VI. Conclusion
A. The science is clear, the evidence is growing
B. Students deserve policies based on biology, not tradition
| 改写前 | 改写后 |
|---|---|
| 10 条杂乱无章的条目 | 6 个逻辑清楚、重点突出的部分 |
| 个人轶事占了一整段 | 在引言中作为简短的引子 |
| 好处分散在文章各处 | 好处归在一个部分里(III) |
| 提到了反方论证却没有反驳 | 设有带具体反驳的反方论证部分(V) |
| 对已经改变的学校的含糊提及 | 带有数据的具体例子(IV) |
| 没有清楚的论点句 | 论点句预告了三个主要的好处 |
在还没有写出一个新句子之前,修改后的提纲就已经把一篇 C 等的文章变成了一篇 B+ 或 A 等的文章。结构现在支撑着论证,而不是削弱它。
不同的文章类型适合不同的提纲结构。下面是一些你可以调整使用的可靠模式。
I. Introduction + thesis
II. Strongest argument
III. Second argument
IV. Third argument (or counterargument + rebuttal)
V. Conclusion
I. Introduction + thesis
II. Subject A (all aspects)
III. Subject B (all aspects, same order)
IV. Analysis: what the comparison reveals
V. Conclusion
I. Introduction + thesis
II. Aspect 1: Subject A vs. Subject B
III. Aspect 2: Subject A vs. Subject B
IV. Aspect 3: Subject A vs. Subject B
V. Conclusion
I. Introduction + thesis
II. Cause 1 (or Effect 1)
III. Cause 2 (or Effect 2)
IV. Cause 3 (or Effect 3)
V. Connections between causes/effects
VI. Conclusion
I. Introduction: define the problem
II. Scope and impact of the problem
III. Proposed solution
IV. How the solution works (implementation)
V. Anticipated objections and responses
VI. Conclusion
| 概念 | 要点 |
|---|---|
| 从提纲到草稿 | 把主要论点变成主题句,把次级论点扩展成论据和分析,加上过渡 |
| 反向提纲 | 用一句话概括现有的每个段落,诊断结构问题 |
| 改写前后的修改 | 把分散的论点重新组织成合乎逻辑的组别,补上缺失的部分,删掉无关的材料 |
| 各文章类型的模式 | 不同的文章类型都有可以调整使用的可靠提纲模板 |
| 最佳做法 | 从非正式提纲开始,根据需要使之正式化,再为草稿列反向提纲来检查结构 |
约6分钟阅读
本节提供拿来就能用的提纲模板、格式规范、常见列提纲错误的汇总,以及一份写作前的规划清单。每当你准备动笔时,都可以把它当作实用的参考。
下面的模板涵盖了最常见的文章类型。照搬这些结构,再填入你自己的内容。根据作业的篇幅和复杂程度,调整正文部分的数量。
这是在时间压力下用起来最快的模板。它适用于 IELTS Task 2、TOEFL Integrated/Independent 和 AP Free Response。
Thesis: [Your main argument in one sentence]
Body 1: [First supporting point]
- Evidence: [Specific fact, example, or statistic]
- So what: [Why this evidence matters]
Body 2: [Second supporting point]
- Evidence: [Specific fact, example, or statistic]
- So what: [Why this evidence matters]
Body 3: [Third supporting point OR counterargument + rebuttal]
- Evidence: [Specific fact, example, or statistic]
- So what: [Why this evidence matters]
Conclusion: [Restate thesis + broader implication]
一篇 40 分钟限时作文的时间分配:
| 阶段 | 时间 |
|---|---|
| 读题并列提纲 | 5 分钟 |
| 起草引言 | 5 分钟 |
| 起草正文段落(3 段) | 20 分钟 |
| 起草结论 | 5 分钟 |
| 校对 | 5 分钟 |
这个模板通过在每个部分加入更多的论据和一个专门的反方论证部分来增加深度。
I. Introduction
A. Hook: [Attention-grabbing opening]
B. Context: [Background the reader needs]
C. Thesis: [Central argument + preview of supporting points]
II. First Supporting Argument
A. Topic sentence: [Claim connected to thesis]
B. Evidence 1: [Primary source, statistic, or example]
C. Analysis of Evidence 1
D. Evidence 2: [Secondary supporting evidence]
E. Analysis of Evidence 2
F. Connection back to thesis
III. Second Supporting Argument
A. Topic sentence: [Claim connected to thesis]
B. Evidence 1: [Primary source, statistic, or example]
C. Analysis of Evidence 1
D. Evidence 2: [Secondary supporting evidence]
E. Analysis of Evidence 2
F. Connection back to thesis
IV. Third Supporting Argument
[Same structure as II and III]
V. Counterargument and Rebuttal
A. Strongest opposing argument: [State it fairly]
B. Why it seems persuasive: [Acknowledge its appeal]
C. Why it fails: [Evidence or reasoning that refutes it]
D. How this strengthens your original argument
VI. Conclusion
A. Restate thesis in new language
B. Synthesize (do not just list) the main points
C. Broader implication, call to action, or forward-looking
statement
研究论文需要更灵活的结构。这个模板包括一个文献综述部分,并允许设置多个正文部分。
I. Introduction
A. Research question or problem statement
B. Why this matters (significance)
C. Thesis or hypothesis
D. Brief overview of methodology (if applicable)
II. Literature Review / Background
A. What previous research has found
B. Gaps in existing knowledge
C. How your paper addresses those gaps
III. Body Section 1: [First major finding or argument]
A. Claim
B. Evidence from research
C. Analysis
D. How this connects to your thesis
IV. Body Section 2: [Second major finding or argument]
[Same structure]
V. Body Section 3: [Third major finding or argument]
[Same structure]
VI. Discussion
A. What the findings mean taken together
B. Limitations of your analysis
C. Implications for the field
D. Suggestions for future research
VII. Conclusion
A. Summary of argument and findings
B. Significance restated
C. Final thought
逐点式(推荐用于大多数文章):
I. Introduction + thesis
II. Point of Comparison 1
A. Subject A
B. Subject B
C. Analysis: what this comparison reveals
III. Point of Comparison 2
A. Subject A
B. Subject B
C. Analysis: what this comparison reveals
IV. Point of Comparison 3
A. Subject A
B. Subject B
C. Analysis: what this comparison reveals
V. Conclusion: overall significance of the comparison
分块式(对象差别很大时更好):
I. Introduction + thesis
II. Subject A
A. Aspect 1
B. Aspect 2
C. Aspect 3
III. Subject B
A. Aspect 1 (same as A's Aspect 1 for parallel structure)
B. Aspect 2
C. Aspect 3
IV. Analysis: what the comparison reveals
V. Conclusion
如果你的老师或学校要求提交正式的提纲,就遵循下面这些标准规范。
标准的层级编号系统交替使用数字和字母:
I. First level (Roman numerals)
A. Second level (capital letters)
1. Third level (Arabic numerals)
a. Fourth level (lowercase letters)
(1) Fifth level (Arabic numerals in parentheses)
(a) Sixth level (lowercase letters in parentheses)
大多数提纲很少超过第三或第四层。如果你需要更多的层级,你的提纲可能太详细了,或者你的分类可能需要重新组织。
同一层级的每一条都应该使用同样的语法结构。如果你第一条罗马数字的条目以动词开头,那么所有罗马数字的条目都应该以动词开头。如果你大写字母的条目是名词短语,就让它们全都保持为名词短语。
平行(正确):
I. Reducing operational costs
II. Improving employee satisfaction
III. Strengthening brand reputation
不平行(错误):
I. Reducing operational costs
II. Employee satisfaction is improved
III. Brand reputation
第一份始终使用动名词短语。第二份把动名词短语、被动分句和光秃秃的名词短语混在了一起。
如果你有次级论点 A,就必须至少有次级论点 B。如果你只有一个次级论点,就应该把它并入上一级的论点。只有一个次级论点,说明你实际上并没有对这个观点进行划分。
错误:
II. Benefits of remote work
A. Cost savings
如果节省成本是唯一的次级论点,要么加上更多的次级论点,要么把它合并:
改正后(选择 1——加上次级论点):
II. Benefits of remote work
A. Cost savings for employers
B. Increased flexibility for employees
C. Access to wider talent pool
改正后(选择 2——合并):
II. The cost savings of remote work
下面是写作者在列提纲时最常犯的错误,并解释了它们为什么会造成问题,以及怎样改正。
有些写作者先起草,只在被要求提交提纲时才列一份。这就失去了列提纲的意义。提纲应该指导写作,而不是事后给写作补记录。例外:反向提纲是一种很有价值的修改工具,但它是对写作前提纲的补充,而不是替代。
改法: 在起草之前列提纲,哪怕只是一份非正式的提纲。在修改时,把反向提纲作为第二步来使用。
有些写作者把提纲列得过于详细,以至于花在规划上的时间比花在写作上的还多。一份有六层缩进、每一层都是完整句子的提纲,往往是一种伪装成高效的拖延。
改法: 让提纲的详细程度与作业相匹配。对于一篇 500 词的文章,一份 10 行的非正式提纲就足够了。对于一篇 5,000 词的研究论文,一份详细的句子式提纲才是合适的。如果你为一篇标准文章列的提纲超过了一页,你就做过头了。
提纲是一份计划,而不是一份合同。那些即使在起草时发现了更好的想法、也拒绝偏离提纲的写作者,会写出僵硬、缺乏生气的文章。提纲应该为文章服务,而不是反过来。
改法: 允许你的提纲在起草过程中不断演变。如果你在写作时发现了一个更好的论证或更合乎逻辑的顺序,就更新提纲,沿着更有力的路径走。
一份观点清单并不是提纲。提纲展示的是层级关系——哪些观点是主要论点,哪些是支撑细节。一份扁平的清单把所有东西都当作同等重要。
清单(不是提纲):
- Cost savings
- Employee satisfaction
- Remote work technology
- Environmental benefits
- Management challenges
- Company culture
提纲(经过组织):
I. Financial benefits
A. Cost savings for employers
B. Reduced commuting costs for employees
II. Workforce benefits
A. Employee satisfaction and flexibility
B. Access to global talent
III. Challenges and solutions
A. Management difficulties --> virtual management tools
B. Culture concerns --> intentional team-building practices
提纲把相关的观点归在一起,确立了层级,并展示了各个论点之间怎样联系。
你提纲中的每个部分都应该与论点句联系起来。如果一条提纲条目既不支撑、展开论点句,也不为它提供背景,它就不属于这篇文章。
改法: 列完提纲后,读一读每个主要论点,问一问:「这直接支撑我的论点句吗?」如果答案是否定的,就删掉它,或者修改你的论点句,把它考虑进去。
对于议论文来说,没有为反方论证做好规划,是一个常见而严重的疏忽。一份只包含支撑论点的提纲,会写出一篇片面的文章,没有正视相反的视角。
改法: 对于任何议论文,都在提纲中为至少一个反方论证和你的反驳设置一个部分。
在开始列提纲之前使用这份清单,确保你已经做好了必要的准备。
列提纲时最关键的决定之一,是你呈现论证的顺序。下面是最常见的几种排序策略。
| 策略 | 怎样运作 | 最适合 |
|---|---|---|
| 最有力的放最前面 | 以你最好的论证开头,立刻建立可信度 | 商务写作、评论文章、读者可能读不完的情况 |
| 最有力的放最后面 | 逐步推向你最有力的论证,以高潮收尾 | 学术文章、希望在结尾取得最大冲击力的说服性写作 |
| 时间顺序 | 按时间顺序呈现论点 | 历史分析、过程解释、叙事性文章 |
| 从原因到结果 | 先讲原因,再说明其后果 | 考察某件事为什么会发生的分析性文章 |
| 从问题到解决方案 | 先界定问题,再提出解决方案 | 政策论文、提案写作 |
| 从简单到复杂 | 从容易理解的论点开始,逐步推向更精深的论点 | 技术写作、面向普通读者的文章 |
对于大多数学术文章,推荐的做法是把最有力的放在最后面。这反映了一篇好演讲的结构:开头扎实,积蓄势头,有力收尾。结论之前的最后一个正文段落,是强调最强的位置。
| 项目 | 指导方针 |
|---|---|
| 限时考试的提纲 | 论点句 + 3 个要点,2-5 分钟 |
| 标准文章的提纲 | 注明论据的词组式提纲,10-20 分钟 |
| 研究论文的提纲 | 对应好来源的句子式提纲,1-3 小时 |
| 编号 | I. / A. / 1. / a. |
| 平行结构 | 每一层使用同样的语法形式 |
| 二的规则 | 有 A 就要有 B;单独的次级论点应该合并 |
| 反方论证 | 在议论文中始终为至少一个反方论证做好规划 |
| 提纲的灵活性 | 如果起草时出现了更好的想法,就更新提纲 |
| 反向提纲 | 起草后概括每个段落,检查结构 |
| 论点的顺序 | 学术写作中通常把最有力的放在最后 |